# Shelter Island Craft Brewery — Shelter Island, New York

> Shelter Island Craft Brewery in Shelter Island, New York, United States scores 2.92 out of 5 — Limited, #537 in New York. 44 beers tracked, mostly IPA.

*Canonical page: <https://finding.beer/brewery/shelter-island-craft-brewery-148/> · data updated 2026-09-08*

Breadcrumb: Breweries → United States → New York → Shelter Island Craft Brewery

Shelter Island Craft Brewery is a brewery in Shelter Island, New York, United States. We grade it Limited, with a score of 2.92 out of 5 on the beer it brews — #537 in New York. Of the 44 beers we track, 39% are IPA and 15% Sour / Other.

## Rating

- Score: 2.92 out of 5
- Grade: Limited 😕 — Most craft beer drinkers pass these by.
- Ranked: #537 in New York · #8,399 in United States · #21,701 worldwide
- Popularity: Barely rated
- Beers tracked: 44

## About

Shelter Island Craft Brewery produce's not great quality beer and has a decent variety of ones to choose from. They are most well known for "114 IPA", which is an American IPA and "Liquid Sunshine", which is a Wheat Beer. Their primary focus is brewing IPAs and Sours.

## What they brew

- IPA — 39% of the beers we track
- Sour / Other — 15% of the beers we track
- Other — 14% of the beers we track
- Wheat Beer — 10% of the beers we track
- Pale Lager — 8% of the beers we track
- Pale Ale — 7% of the beers we track
- Saison — 7% of the beers we track

## Find them

- Address: 55 North Ferry Road, Shelter Island, New York, United States
- Coordinates: 41.07139850000001, -72.33954330000002

## Breweries nearby

- [Greenport Harbor Brewing Company](https://finding.beer/brewery/greenport-harbor-brewing-company-218.md) — 3.83, Fine — Greenport, New York — 2.4 mi away
- [Kidd Squid Brewing Co.](https://finding.beer/brewery/kidd-squid-brewing-co-29480.md) — 4.17, Great — Sag Harbor, New York — 5.4 mi away
- [Cantina Cantina](https://finding.beer/brewery/cantina-cantina-26364.md) — 4.17, Great — Peconic, New York — 6.6 mi away
- [Springs Brewery](https://finding.beer/brewery/springs-brewery-28748.md) — 4.21, Great — East Hampton, New York — 11 mi away
- [Eastern Front Brewing](https://finding.beer/brewery/eastern-front-brewing-32657.md) — 3.72, Fine — Mattituck, New York — 11 mi away
- [The Branch Brewing Company](https://finding.beer/brewery/the-branch-brewing-company-35393.md) — 3.56, Poor — Mattituck, New York — 12 mi away
- [Southampton Publick House](https://finding.beer/brewery/southampton-publick-house-3623.md) — 3.06, Limited — Southampton, New York — 13 mi away
- [Jamesport Farm Brewery](https://finding.beer/brewery/jamesport-farm-brewery-106.md) — 3.53, Poor — Riverhead, New York — 15 mi away

## Rankings this brewery appears in

- [Best breweries in New York](https://finding.beer/breweries/united-states/new-york.md)
- [Best breweries in United States](https://finding.beer/breweries/united-states.md)

---

Finding Beer scores breweries on the beer they brew rather than on the venue. Method: <https://finding.beer/how-we-rank.md>. Rankings by place: <https://finding.beer/breweries.md>. The iPhone app adds a live map of what is around you: https://apps.apple.com/us/app/finding-beer/id1082135126