# Old Tappan Brewing Company — Bayville, New York

> Old Tappan Brewing Company in Bayville, New York, United States scores 3.47 out of 5 — Poor, #423 in New York. 58 beers tracked, mostly IPA.

*Canonical page: <https://finding.beer/brewery/old-tappan-brewing-company-19106/> · data updated 2026-08-30*

Breadcrumb: Breweries → United States → New York → Old Tappan Brewing Company

Old Tappan Brewing Company is a brewery in Bayville, New York, United States. We grade it Poor, with a score of 3.47 out of 5 on the beer it brews — #423 in New York. Of the 58 beers we track, 33% are IPA and 26% Pale Ale.

## Rating

- Score: 3.47 out of 5
- Grade: Poor 😐 — Not bad beer so much as unremarkable beer.
- Ranked: #423 in New York · #7,144 in United States · #12,198 worldwide
- Popularity: Barely rated
- Beers tracked: 58

## What they brew

- IPA — 33% of the beers we track
- Pale Ale — 26% of the beers we track
- Stout / Porter — 10% of the beers we track
- Other — 9% of the beers we track
- Brown Ale — 8% of the beers we track
- Wheat Beer — 7% of the beers we track
- Amber Ale — 7% of the beers we track

## Find them

- Address: 37 Ludlam Avenue, Bayville, New York, United States
- Coordinates: 40.9057261, -73.54897609999999
- Website: https://www.oldtappanbrewingcompany.com/

## Breweries nearby

- [Noble Savage Brewing Company](https://finding.beer/brewery/noble-savage-brewing-company-18939.md) — 4.72, Exceptional — Glen Cove, New York — 5.1 mi away
- [Garvies Point Brewery](https://finding.beer/brewery/garvies-point-brewery-137.md) — 3.93, Fine — Glen Cove, New York — 5.5 mi away
- [Six Harbors Brewing Company](https://finding.beer/brewery/six-harbors-brewing-company-87.md) — 3.54, Poor — Huntington, New York — 6.8 mi away
- [Stay Green Brewing Co.](https://finding.beer/brewery/stay-green-brewing-co-27756.md) — 3.74, Fine — Huntington, New York — 6.9 mi away
- [The Blind Bat Brewery](https://finding.beer/brewery/the-blind-bat-brewery-220.md) — 3.46, Poor — Centerport, New York — 8.6 mi away
- [Half Full Brewery](https://finding.beer/brewery/half-full-brewery-2052.md) — 3.49, Poor — Stamford, Connecticut — 9.2 mi away
- [Greenwich Brewing Company](https://finding.beer/brewery/greenwich-brewing-company-35783.md) — 3.88, Fine — Greenwich, Connecticut — 9.4 mi away
- [Barclay Brewing Co.](https://finding.beer/brewery/barclay-brewing-co-18022.md) — 4.16, Great — Mamaroneck, New York — 10 mi away

## Rankings this brewery appears in

- [Best breweries in New York](https://finding.beer/breweries/united-states/new-york.md)
- [Best breweries in United States](https://finding.beer/breweries/united-states.md)

---

Finding Beer scores breweries on the beer they brew rather than on the venue. Method: <https://finding.beer/how-we-rank.md>. Rankings by place: <https://finding.beer/breweries.md>. The iPhone app adds a live map of what is around you: https://apps.apple.com/us/app/finding-beer/id1082135126