# Nightmare Brewing Company — Bay Shore, New York

> Nightmare Brewing Company in Bay Shore, New York, United States scores 4.37 out of 5 — Great, #39 in New York. 36 beers tracked, mostly IPA.

*Canonical page: <https://finding.beer/brewery/nightmare-brewing-company-1160/> · data updated 2026-09-09*

Breadcrumb: Breweries → United States → New York → Nightmare Brewing Company

Nightmare Brewing Company is a brewery in Bay Shore, New York, United States. We grade it Great, with a score of 4.37 out of 5 on the beer it brews — #39 in New York. Of the 36 beers we track, 51% are IPA and 30% Sour / Other.

## Rating

- Score: 4.37 out of 5
- Grade: Great 😀 — Consistently produce world-class beer.
- Ranked: #39 in New York · #385 in United States · #575 worldwide
- Popularity: Well rated
- Beers tracked: 36

## About

Nightmare Brewing Company produce's high quality beer and has a decent variety of ones to choose from. They are most well known for "Drawn & Quartered", which is an Imperial IPA and "Exposure", which is an Imperial IPA. Their primary focus is brewing IPAs and Sours.

## What they brew

- IPA — 51% of the beers we track
- Sour / Other — 30% of the beers we track
- Stout / Porter — 16% of the beers we track
- Other — 3% of the beers we track

## Find them

- Address: Bay Shore, New York, United States
- Coordinates: 40.7250986, -73.2453946
- Website: https://www.nightmarebrewingco.com/

## Breweries nearby

- [Take Two Brewery](https://finding.beer/brewery/take-two-brewery-33391.md) — 3.92, Fine — Bay Shore, New York — 0.4 mi away
- [HopWin's Brewery](https://finding.beer/brewery/hopwins-brewery-25014.md) — 3.82, Fine — Bay Shore, New York — 1.7 mi away
- [Rites Brewing Company](https://finding.beer/brewery/rites-brewing-company-36053.md) — 4.33, Great — Bay Shore, New York — 1.7 mi away
- [Beaver Dam Brewing Company](https://finding.beer/brewery/beaver-dam-brewing-company-36582.md) — 3.49, Poor — Islip, New York — 2.5 mi away
- [Ghost Brewing Company](https://finding.beer/brewery/ghost-brewing-company-27609.md) — 3.83, Fine — Bay Shore, New York — 2.7 mi away
- [Great South Bay Brewery](https://finding.beer/brewery/great-south-bay-brewery-212.md) — 3.53, Poor — Bay Shore, New York — 2.7 mi away
- [Secatogue Brewing Co.](https://finding.beer/brewery/secatogue-brewing-co-32604.md) — 3.90, Fine — West Islip, New York — 3.2 mi away
- [Breslau Brewing Company](https://finding.beer/brewery/breslau-brewing-company-33407.md) — 3.78, Fine — Lindenhurst, New York — 7.3 mi away

## Rankings this brewery appears in

- [Best breweries in New York](https://finding.beer/breweries/united-states/new-york.md)
- [Best breweries in United States](https://finding.beer/breweries/united-states.md)

---

Finding Beer scores breweries on the beer they brew rather than on the venue. Method: <https://finding.beer/how-we-rank.md>. Rankings by place: <https://finding.beer/breweries.md>. The iPhone app adds a live map of what is around you: https://apps.apple.com/us/app/finding-beer/id1082135126