# Butternuts Beer & Ale — Garrattsville, New York

> Butternuts Beer & Ale in Garrattsville, New York, United States scores 2.88 out of 5 — Limited, #542 in New York. 50 beers tracked, mostly Pale Ale.

*Canonical page: <https://finding.beer/brewery/butternuts-beer-ale-222/> · data updated 2026-08-13*

Breadcrumb: Breweries → United States → New York → Butternuts Beer & Ale

Butternuts Beer & Ale is a brewery in Garrattsville, New York, United States. We grade it Limited, with a score of 2.88 out of 5 on the beer it brews — #542 in New York. Of the 50 beers we track, 41% are Pale Ale and 26% Stout / Porter.

## Rating

- Score: 2.88 out of 5
- Grade: Limited 😕 — Most craft beer drinkers pass these by.
- Ranked: #542 in New York · #8,456 in United States · #22,747 worldwide
- Popularity: Well rated
- Beers tracked: 50

## About

Established in 2005, Butternuts Beer and Ale is located on a 120 acre farm in the idyllic Butternut Valley. Located in a renovated dairy barn, we brew a wide mix of ales and lagers. Water is sourced from our own spring and lends to our signature flavor. Our Porklap Ale and Moo Thunder stout are available year-round. Our Burning Banjo beer line is our seasonal and rotational line offering unique styles inspired by our direct fired kettle. Stop by for a tasting, enjoy the country setting and take home a growler. Seasonal Taproom hours and events can be found on our website www.butternuts beer.com. Join our mailing list to stay connected.

## What they brew

- Pale Ale — 41% of the beers we track
- Stout / Porter — 26% of the beers we track
- IPA — 18% of the beers we track
- Wheat Beer — 11% of the beers we track
- Other — 4% of the beers we track

## Find them

- Address: 4020 New York 51, Garrattsville, New York, United States
- Coordinates: 42.62095009999999, -75.188936
- Website: http://www.butternutsbeerandale.com/

## Same owner

- [Burning Banjo Brewing](https://finding.beer/brewery/burning-banjo-brewing-33024.md) — Garrattsville, United States

## Breweries nearby

- [Burning Banjo Brewing](https://finding.beer/brewery/burning-banjo-brewing-33024.md) — 3.28, Poor — Garrattsville, New York — 2 mi away
- [High Burl Brewery](https://finding.beer/brewery/high-burl-brewery-22786.md) — 3.80, Fine — Burlington Flats, New York — 7.3 mi away
- [Dobler's Brewery And Tavern](https://finding.beer/brewery/doblers-brewery-and-tavern-5315.md) — 2.61, Limited — Mount Vision, New York — 8 mi away
- [Council Rock Brewery](https://finding.beer/brewery/council-rock-brewery-6986.md) — 3.03, Limited — Cooperstown, New York — 12 mi away
- [Red Shed Brewery](https://finding.beer/brewery/red-shed-brewery-6875.md) — 3.47, Poor — Cooperstown, New York — 12 mi away
- [Muddy River Farm Brewery](https://finding.beer/brewery/muddy-river-farm-brewery-33083.md) — 3.80, Fine — Oneonta, New York — 12 mi away
- [Brewery Ommegang](https://finding.beer/brewery/brewery-ommegang-2036.md) — 3.89, Fine — Cooperstown, New York — 12 mi away
- [Cooperstown Brewing Company](https://finding.beer/brewery/cooperstown-brewing-company-2035.md) — 3.01, Limited — Milford, New York — 13 mi away

## Rankings this brewery appears in

- [Best breweries in New York](https://finding.beer/breweries/united-states/new-york.md)
- [Best breweries in United States](https://finding.beer/breweries/united-states.md)

---

Finding Beer scores breweries on the beer they brew rather than on the venue. Method: <https://finding.beer/how-we-rank.md>. Rankings by place: <https://finding.beer/breweries.md>. The iPhone app adds a live map of what is around you: https://apps.apple.com/us/app/finding-beer/id1082135126