# Big Inlet Brewing — Mayville, New York > Big Inlet Brewing in Mayville, New York, United States scores 3.53 out of 5 — Poor, #366 in New York. 61 beers tracked, mostly IPA. *Canonical page: · data updated 2026-08-28* Breadcrumb: Breweries → United States → New York → Big Inlet Brewing Big Inlet Brewing is a brewery in Mayville, New York, United States. We grade it Poor, with a score of 3.53 out of 5 on the beer it brews — #366 in New York. Of the 61 beers we track, 28% are IPA and 18% Other. ## Rating - Score: 3.53 out of 5 - Grade: Poor 😐 — Not bad beer so much as unremarkable beer. - Ranked: #366 in New York · #6,480 in United States · #10,653 worldwide - Popularity: Lightly rated - Beers tracked: 61 ## About Big Inlet Brewing is the result of years of brainstorming and hard work by close friends and relatives - Randy Henderson, Brent Henderson, Mike Starks and John Weise. Our goal is to provide the highest quality beer available in a farm-oriented, family-friendly environment. Our home on Elm Flats Road in Mayville, NY was once an actual working farm, complete with horse and cow stalls. It has been fully converted into a small batch brewery with farm-related décor. Including 1,600 sf of brewing floor as well as 2,300 sf of tasting/gathering room, we have plenty of space for your enjoyment. Using NYS and locally grown/produced ingredients, Big Inlet Brewing produces small batch, handcrafted beers designed and brewed by our head brewer, Mike Starks along with brewer John Weise. Mike and John each have more than a decade of home-brewing experience and Mike has also won a number of competitions for his brewing skills. Randy and Brent are hands on owners who share a common passion – to provide guests with the product (beer) and service that they deserve in a way that displays our dedication to Chautauqua County and Western New York. Ultimately, beer is about a good time. We look forward to making new friends, sharing our beer, and providing that service and environment where you have just that – a good time. Thank you for visiting Big Inlet Brewing! ## What they brew - IPA — 28% of the beers we track - Other — 18% of the beers we track - Pale Ale — 17% of the beers we track - Sour / Other — 13% of the beers we track - Stout / Porter — 13% of the beers we track - Saison — 6% of the beers we track - Wheat Beer — 5% of the beers we track ## Find them - Address: 6169 Elm Flat Road, Mayville, New York, United States - Coordinates: 42.2703949, -79.4730598 - Website: http://www.biginletbrewing.com/ ## Breweries nearby - [Grace & Abe's](https://finding.beer/brewery/grace-abes-25181.md) — 3.44, Poor — Westfield, New York — 6.5 mi away - [Five & 20 Spirits & Brewing](https://finding.beer/brewery/five-20-spirits-brewing-1717.md) — 3.45, Poor — Westfield, New York — 7.2 mi away - [Southern Tier Brewing Company](https://finding.beer/brewery/southern-tier-brewing-company-228.md) — 3.87, Fine — Lakewood, New York — 14 mi away - [7 Sins Brewery](https://finding.beer/brewery/7-sins-brewery-2321.md) — 2.94, Limited — Ripley, New York — 14 mi away - [Arundel Cellars & Brewing Co.](https://finding.beer/brewery/arundel-cellars-brewing-co-3232.md) — 3.01, Limited — North East, Pennsylvania — 17 mi away - [GoWanda Brewing at the Wicked Glen](https://finding.beer/brewery/gowanda-brewing-at-the-wicked-glen-33094.md) — 3.22, Poor — Gowanda, New York — 30 mi away - [Wicked Warren's](https://finding.beer/brewery/wicked-warrens-32881.md) — 3.88, Fine — Warren, Pennsylvania — 34 mi away - [Bent Run Brewing Company](https://finding.beer/brewery/bent-run-brewing-company-27905.md) — 3.79, Fine — Warren, Pennsylvania — 34 mi away ## Rankings this brewery appears in - [Best breweries in New York](https://finding.beer/breweries/united-states/new-york.md) - [Best breweries in United States](https://finding.beer/breweries/united-states.md) --- Finding Beer scores breweries on the beer they brew rather than on the venue. Method: . Rankings by place: . The iPhone app adds a live map of what is around you: https://apps.apple.com/us/app/finding-beer/id1082135126